Defeat Lust & Pornography couple looking out over water
Defeat Lust & Pornography 3 minute read

Porn and the Desire Dilemma

Last Updated: March 15, 2021

We human beings have a problem–we are creatures of infinite desires. We do not simply want joy or pleasure or love or anything else—we want these things to an infinite degree. We not only want to live happily, we want to live happily ever after.

This is a true dilemma for a finite creature. For being finite means having limits. Yet, our desires have no limits. They are in-finite. No sooner have we possessed what we believe will make us happy than we realize that it is limited and therefore inadequate. Our satisfaction fades and our desire reawakens even stronger than before.

Nevertheless, we again and again seek to satisfy our hearts with finite things. With food, with sex, with social media, with Netflix, with shopping, and a host of other things. Yet these things never fill the void. They are hollow substitutes that leave us empty and afraid to face our true need.

Porn and Communion

As strange as it may seem, porn, too, is an attempt to satisfy our infinite longing. After all, we are creatures made for union and communion. We long to find our completeness in another. “It is not good for man to be alone,” God said in the beginning, and in making us male and female, He wrote this fact in our very biology. We were made for one another. We need one another.

Porn is so compelling because it sells itself as the perfect substitute for real communion and relationship. It stimulates our desire to be loved and wanted to the breaking point. It is the ultimate fantasy of fulfillment.

Yet it can never satisfy. It betrays us every time and keeps us coming back for more. Porn promises us that one more time will be enough—and yet it never is. And not only does porn not satisfy our thirst for love, it leaves us thirstier than before. Like a parched man drinking saltwater in a desert, it can only make our thirst worse.

We desire communion, but porn leaves us isolated. We desire love, and porn destroys any vestige of it. We desire wholeness, and porn leaves us broken. It is the ultimate deceiver and destroyer.

Desire or disorder?

So what is the solution? What are we to do with this desire dilemma?

One thing we should not do is decry the desire. One of the great mistakes Christians often make is to confuse erotic desire with the sin of lust. It is easy to see why. Faced with a growing porn problem, it is easy to jump to the conclusion that the problem lies with our desire for sex. If we could simply shut off or suppress our erotic desire, we think, porn would go away on its own.

But the fact is the opposite. Our erotic desire for union with another is ultimately not the problem. It is that we are attempting to satisfy it with a cheap and finite counterfeit. For eros is a kind of love and it was given to us by God. It is simply the love of union. It is an intense longing to become one with another. This profound love is prefigured in the human love relationship and marital union. Our desire for our spouse is intended to mirror the love of God for His creatures, and His self-giving on their behalf.

I will say it again: Eros is good and holy. It is simply the desire for union and completion in another person. But when this desire aims at the wrong target, when it becomes disordered and misdirected, problems arise and sin enters the picture. It is like an eating disorder that distorts and misdirects the healthy desire for food. The solution, then, is not to deny the desire, but to fulfill it in the God-designed way.

Directing Our Desire to the Heavens

Eros, erotic love, is incredibly powerful, perhaps even the most powerful desire of the heart. It is the rocket fuel intended to launch us upward into the arms of the God who loves us, and thus to find our completion in Him. Simply, eros was meant to be oriented toward God and fulfilled by Him. For only an infinite God can satisfy an infinite desire.

Our culture needs to hear there is satisfaction for their hungry hearts. As the great Christian writer and apologist, C.S. Lewis, put it, “No soul that seriously and constantly desires joy will ever miss it. Those who seek find. To those who knock it is opened.” But satisfaction can never be found in porn or hookups or any other substitute. It can only be found in God alone.

Sex is good and beautiful. It is a portrait of God’s intense love for us—the love of a husband for his bride. Indeed, throughout the scriptures, the Lord speaks of Himself as a bridegroom and the church as His bride. His love for us is that intense and passionate. He loved us to the point of giving His body and blood for us—even unto death.

Until we realize that our destiny, the fulfillment of all our desires, is in God alone, we will be left hungry and dissatisfied by the things of this world. But if we see the gifts of God as good, but ultimately as signposts orienting us back to Him, we will be filled with a joy that never ends.

  1. Fred

    Really? When God said – before the fall – that it was not good that man be alone, He created Eve. If a relationship with God Himself were all that is necessary to get rid of humanity’s loneliness, why would God create Eve? I know devout Christians who struggle with loneliness all of their lives. Clearly there is more involved here and I do not think an over-simplification is helpful. I would add that, unfortunatelly, neither does marriage necessarily solve the issues. Lots of people (about twenty percent of marriages) are in sexless marriages. Their sincere prayers to God are unanswered. What is the longest you have prayed about something? I know a man who has prayed about his sexless marriage for thirty-five years. God hasn’t answered. Speaking frankly, much of the counsel that is supposed to solve unfulfilled sexual desire and extreme loneliness – both of which fuel pornography – is worthless. It often sounds like, “just do, A and B and C, and eventually you won’t mind being miserable.

  2. Robert

    Want to control my sexual desires

    • Keith Rose

      Thanks for reaching out to us! Sexual desire is a good thing, and as the article explains God created us as sexual beings. However, many of us feel controlled by sexual desire and act out in unwanted sinful behaviors. Your sexual desire does not have to equal acting out! God can change an ungodly lust into holy desire. We believe that accountability relationships are one means that God has given us to control unwanted sexual behaviors. Here’s an article that gives some suggestions for where to find an accountability partner who can be an ally for you in the fight!

      Blessings,

      Keith

  3. Johan

    eager to be set free

    • Chris McKenna

      Hi, what have you tried? This post might help with some actions you can take.
      Chris

  4. Pauline STONE

    I’m deeply confused about having sex with my husband. While he is going though therapy for sex addiction and pornography… I feel that it would not be wise to to do this. Is there a answer? Somewhere?

    • Kay Bruner

      Do you want to have sex with him? That’s really the only question that matters, in my opinion. You are under no obligation to provide sex to your husband. Choose what’s healthy for you, sexually, and follow through. if sex is a thing that substitutes for emotional intimacy, if sex is a thing you do to stop him from acting out, if sex is a thing that’s a source of manipulation or obligation then it doesn’t sound like a healthy option to me. It’s perfectly fine to let him get clean and sober before you decide what kind of sexual relationship you’re able to have with him. Peace to you, Kay

    • Anthony

      Have sex when he’s comfortable

    • Scott Burn

      Pauline, you absolutely must continue to be sexually intimate with your husband if you desire to obey God and if you love your husband. Those who will tell you otherwise like Kay, simply have no love for God’s perfect holy word.

      1 Corinthians 7 speaks too clearly. You may only abstain from sex with your spouse with mutual consent. Your body does not belong to you, but belongs to your husband. Your husbands body also belongs to you not to him. Corinthians says “do NOT deprive one another except for a time of fasting with mutual consent. Notice the “mutual consent.”

      The scary truth in this verse is where God says through Paul His servant as he writes to the Church. If you deprive the spouse sexually, you are responsible for giving Satan a foothold in your marriage.

      I hope this helps and I hope and pray that you desire to please God and listen to His perfect word, more than you desire to please or listen to jaded rebellious liberal women who have cast off their first faith for love of self over love of the Lord Jesus Christ.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related in Defeat Lust & Pornography

Editor's Picks

Two young men studying the Bible.

Defeat Lust & Pornography

5 Ways Accountability Can Deepen Your Relationship With God

You probably recognize that accountability is a powerful tool for behavior change.…

4 minute read

Read Post

Editor's Picks

Man looking at his Bible.

Defeat Lust & Pornography

When Porn Leads To Despair

For the enemy has pursued me, crushing me to the ground, making…

4 minute read

Read Post

Editor's Picks

boy before first Eucharist in a catholic church. child in white clothes with a candle in the church

Defeat Lust & Pornography

Everything Changed With a Video

I was a 14-year-old Catholic. I sang with the church choir, attended…

4 minute read

Read Post

Editor's Picks

boy enjoying game console at home

Defeat Lust & Pornography

Willing To Be Healed

Ten years old. That’s when it started. I had begun to feel…

5 minute read

Read Post

Editor's Picks

Young man kneeling in a church sanctuary.

Defeat Lust & Pornography

Faith and Porn: Jonathan’s Story

To explain my struggle against this sin is to, in essence, describe…

5 minute read

Read Post

Editor's Picks

Image of Beth Davis.

Defeat Lust & Pornography

Beth Davis’s Story: Jesus Set Me Free

Like so many people, I was exposed to pornography at a young…

4 minute read

Read Post

Related in Defeat Lust & Pornography

Two young men studying the Bible.

Defeat Lust & Pornography

5 Ways Accountability Can Deepen Your Relationship With God

You probably recognize that accountability is a powerful tool for behavior change.…

You probably recognize that accountability is a powerful tool for behavior change. The business world, the self-help world, and the porn-recovery world all acknowledge the vital importance of accountability.   But it can be much…

4 minute read

0 comments

Man looking at his Bible.

Defeat Lust & Pornography

When Porn Leads To Despair

For the enemy has pursued me, crushing me to the ground, making…

For the enemy has pursued me, crushing me to the ground, making me live in darkness like those long dead. My spirit is weak within me; my heart is overcome with dismay. Psalm 143:3-4 Has…

4 minute read

0 comments

boy before first Eucharist in a catholic church. child in white clothes with a candle in the church

Defeat Lust & Pornography

Everything Changed With a Video

I was a 14-year-old Catholic. I sang with the church choir, attended…

I was a 14-year-old Catholic. I sang with the church choir, attended Mass every weekend, and participated in youth group as often as I could. My friends and family had always warned me about the…

4 minute read

0 comments

boy enjoying game console at home

Defeat Lust & Pornography

Willing To Be Healed

Ten years old. That’s when it started. I had begun to feel…

Ten years old. That’s when it started. I had begun to feel strange urges to look at women without their clothes on, but couldn’t bring myself to talk about these feelings with my parents. Instead,…

5 minute read

0 comments

Young man kneeling in a church sanctuary.

Defeat Lust & Pornography

Faith and Porn: Jonathan’s Story

To explain my struggle against this sin is to, in essence, describe…

To explain my struggle against this sin is to, in essence, describe my faith journey as a whole. So, let’s start there. I was raised in a Christian home, albeit one that didn’t actively have…

5 minute read

0 comments

Image of Beth Davis.

Defeat Lust & Pornography

Beth Davis’s Story: Jesus Set Me Free

Like so many people, I was exposed to pornography at a young…

Like so many people, I was exposed to pornography at a young age—maybe eleven or twelve. I wasn’t looking for it and no one showed it to me. I stumbled on it accidentally.  I knew…

4 minute read

0 comments